The Customer or the Company Line

I was walking out of a meeting in New York yesterday and noticed that I had a missed call -- It was American Express who had called to alert me that someone in London was trying to charge $500 in telecommunications equipment (most likely, mobile phones) on my card.

Later that night, I was online paying my Capital One MasterCard and found that someone used my card on December 14th to purchase something with a vendor based in Riyadh, Saudi Arabia...and that person wasn't me.  Christmas is the high season for credit card fraud and I was living it. The only two credit cards I have were both under attack.

The way the two companies dealt with the fraud situation was so different that it became a real time case study on the "best" and "worst" practices for dealing with customers.  The key difference came down to the rep's ability to deal with me as a customer, versus sticking to the company policy.

The Best and the Worst

Detecting Fraud

American Express
I had been in London a couple of weeks ago, and most likely, one of the night clerks at the hotel where I stayed sold my Amex card number.  American Express, knowing that I had recently purchased train tickets to New York the day before, figured out that I couldn't be in two places at once, and stopped the transaction from going through.

Capital One
Clueless I had to report the fraud.  Granted the two transactions were only $10.50 each, but the location of the transactions should have flagged them for further investigation.  I caught them more than a week after the charges were made, Capital One had plenty of time to detect and investigate.  Living in McLean, VA, which happens to be the headquarters of Capital One, I know folks who work there, and having had MasterCard as a client for the past six years, I know a good bit about the credit card business, and CapOne.

I know that CapOne has very sophisticated models for segmenting and targeting customers, analyzing purchasing behavior, etc.  They have no lack of intelligence or technology that would prevent them from detecting fraud, it just may be a matter of focus.

Dealing with Fraud
American Express
Closed my account, alerted the merchant, and sent me a new card via Fedex.  It arrived the next day.

Capital One
Questioned me not one, but three times about whether I knew the merchant and if I had made the purchase.  I asked the CapOne rep to give me more information on the transaction.  She said she couldn't because the details were in Arabic.  I pulled the website, and it was in Arabic.  Despite not speaking or reading Arabic, and stating that several times, I was questioned about the transaction repeatedly.

After closing the account, I was then told a new card would be sent in 5-7 days, and that a form would be sent that I would need to fill out and return.  I asked what additional information they would need that I hadn't already reported.  The rep didn't have an answer, only telling that it was company policy.  At that point, I was "done" and ask for a manager.

I asked the same question to the managers, again the same answer.  I then reminded her that the date was 12/21, the last week before Christmas, and both of my credit cards were used fraudulently.  She said that she understood and would get a new card out to me in 2-3 days.   At that point, I asked for her manager, and finally, I was transferred to the Fraud department.  

Allen was nice enough, and was able to explain the reason for the form.  They needed a signature authorizing that I did not make the transactions so they could dispute the case.  I asked Allen if they were recording our conversation (as Amex did), and if we could just use that to support the case.  The answer was "No. We need the form."  Allen did say that he understood my situation, and would express a new card to me in 2-3 days.

Dealing with the Customer  
Over the years, I've done a good bit of research on defining the "Customer Experience."  When you ask customers what they want, the answers are fairly consistent regardless of company or industry:

• Know me - customers want companies to know them and understand their situation...how their product or services fits a need.  They also want them to anticipate and serve their needs.  With the increased use of social media, that has only increased. 
• Serve me - resolve my issues quickly...turn the "unpleasant into the pleasant."  Remember that I'm the customer, and I have options.  
• Empower me - give me access to resolve my own issues, or empower the employee that I'm speaking with to do it for me.

It sounds simple but it's, as I just experienced, difficult to execute.  The CapOne reps and managers were very nice but they weren't empowered to resolve my issue, or go off script.  Both call centers were outsourced, and probably all reps and managers I spoke with were following company policy and scripts.  The difference was that Amex knew my situation, anticipated my concerns, and resolved my issue in one phone call with one rep -- efficiently and stress free.

Two shopping days left, what's in my wallet?   American Express.